Cinnamon Ice Cream!

August 22
14 Comments

Cinnamon ice cream is one of my family’s favorite summertime treats!  Actually, we often make this indulgent recipe throughout the year…and since cinnamon is the main flavor, it’s wonderful to serve during autumn AND the holidays too!  The inspiration for this yummy dessert was sparked after sampling something similar in an ice cream parlor in Indiana.  It was a favorite place for my mom to go when she was a kid, and it’s still operating today!  Because this shop is so far away, we concocted our own version to make whenever we got the craving!  Today I’d like to share this easy recipe with you…and also a sweet way to serve it!  Summer might be winding down, but there’s always room for ice cream!

we all scream for cinnamon ice cream!

it can be really easy to set up a simple & festive ice cream station to dish out this icy treat…(grab the printable recipe at the end of the post)

cinnamon ice cream cart

i used a rustic garden “cart” draped with a garland and filled the top with the cutest accessories from my favorite dollar spot!

ic cream cart

let’s start with this tray…the cutest right?  i love picking up little trays at great prices.  they’re so wonderful for serving treats, even right from the counter!

ice cream party supplies

i also grabbed some acrylic cone holders from the economy bins.  i love how they don’t hide the message on the tray!

ice cream party ideas & recipes

dropping an ice cream spoon in each cone not only looks darling but can be handy too!

ice cream spoons

matching napkins are never necessary for a party…but they sure add a fun detail!

ice cream party supplies

and i can’t tell you how much i LOVE this silicon container!  you can make the ice cream ahead and it can go from freezer right to the party table!

ice cream carton

the detail on the lid is my favorite…

ice cream carton

how fun that this delicious ice cream has such a delicious color…and just happened to match all the party goods!

cinnamon ice cream

i hope you try this easy recipe and serve up some sweet fun to your peeps this summer…or fall…or winter…

cinnamon ice cream cart

celebrate late summer with cinnamon ice cream!

homemade cinnamon ice cream
Cinnamon Ice Cream
Print Recipe
Servings Prep Time
10 1/2 cup servings 5 minutes
Cook Time
25 minutes
Servings Prep Time
10 1/2 cup servings 5 minutes
Cook Time
25 minutes
homemade cinnamon ice cream
Cinnamon Ice Cream
Print Recipe
Servings Prep Time
10 1/2 cup servings 5 minutes
Cook Time
25 minutes
Servings Prep Time
10 1/2 cup servings 5 minutes
Cook Time
25 minutes
Ingredients
Servings: 1/2 cup servings
Instructions
  1. In a medium bowl, use a hand mixer or a whisk to combine the milk and the sugar until the sugar is dissolved, about 1-2 minutes
  2. Stir in the heavy cream, vanilla, cinnamon and food color. Taste between additions of cinnamon.
  3. Pour into the frozen bowl of the ice cream maker and churn for 20-25 minutes or until cream has set up. (it will be more like soft-serve consistency right from the churn, but will set hard in the freezer)
  4. Place ice cream in airtight container and keep in the freezer until ready to serve.

pin for later~

Cinnamon ice cream recipe and fun decorations!

product guide~

Target:  tray, cone “vase”, acrylic cone holder, napkins, ice cream spoons  (all in the dollar spot)

HomeGoods:  ice cream container

Hobby Lobbysimilar garland

Cutcoice cream scoop

 

  1. Anonymous

    August 22

    I can’t wait to try this recipe! Thank you, Lori!

    • Lori

      August 27

      Oh I hope you love it! It’s one of our favorites!!

  2. Jackie

    August 27

    I love cinnamon and ice cream so I think I’ll have to try!

    • Lori

      August 27

      We really love it and it’s such a simple and easy recipe! Hope you like it as much as we do!

  3. Holly

    August 28

    It’s been years since I’ve made ice cream! How fun! I just love the colors for this ice cream party, too!

    • Lori

      August 29

      Thanks Holly! We love making ice cream now that there are so many easy & affordable machines out there now! 🙂

  4. Partieswithacause

    August 31

    Printed the recipe (yep….one of those old school chefs!) and I’m totally making this for my family. I love cinnamon flavor.

    • Lori

      September 4

      Oh yay!! I hope you love it!! We only add the pink coloring because that was the color of the ice cream at my mom’s childhood ice cream shop! 🙂 It would be pretty just natural too!

  5. Press Print Party!

    September 2

    We have an ice cream machine too but we’ve never tried cinnamon…. yum.

    • Lori

      September 4

      Oh we love it so much! Honestly you can just add it to any vanilla recipe!! 🙂

  6. Susan

    September 6

    Love all the ice cream party inspo! Your recipe
    Sounds absolutely delicious

    • Lori

      September 6

      Thanks Susan! It’s one of our favorites!!

  7. This ice cream sounds delicious and I especially love that it’s pink! SO fun and unexpected! Those spoons in the cones are a cute touch too!

    • Lori

      September 11

      Oh it’s our most favorite!! We don’t actually have to color it pink, but that’s the color of the ice cream from the shop my mom went to so we wanted to make ours the same! 🙂

Giggle With Me!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.